Cocktail mixers are key ingredients that help transform basic spirits into complex and tasty cocktails. These mixers come in various forms, like syrups, bitters, and fruit juices, each adding unique flavors and elements to a drink. Whether you’re a home bartender or a seasoned professional, having the right mixers on hand can elevate your cocktail-making game.
When choosing cocktail mixers, it’s important to consider several factors. Ingredients are crucial; high-quality, natural ingredients usually deliver better taste. The mixers’ shelf life and storage conditions can affect their usability. Some mixers might require refrigeration after opening, while others are shelf-stable. Understanding these details can help you make an informed purchase and ensure your cocktails taste their best.
With so many options on the market, it can be tricky to find the best cocktail mixers for your needs. To help, we’ve tested and reviewed a variety of mixers to identify the top choices for flavor and versatility.
Best Cocktail Mixers
Below is our full list of the best cocktail mixers.
Thoughtfully Skinny Cocktail Mixer Set
Ideal for those who want to enjoy a variety of cocktails at home without the extra calories.
Pros
- Great variety of flavors
- Pre-measured for convenience
- Vegan and dietary-friendly
Cons
- Bottles can be hard to open
- Flavor can be too simple for some
- Does not fit in all glassware
This Thoughtfully Skinny Cocktail Mixer Set offers a delightful range of flavors like Margarita, Moscow Mule, and Mojito. The mixers are pre-measured, making it super easy to enjoy your favorite drinks at home. Plus, they are sugar-free and vegan, which is a big plus for health-conscious folks.
We recently tried this set during a get-together, and it was a hit. Each mixer adds a nice touch to regular cocktails, making them taste fresh and unique. The packaging is attractive and makes the set perfect for gifting. However, we did have some trouble opening a few of the bottles, which required a bit more effort than expected.
On the taste front, some might find the flavors a bit too straightforward. Don’t expect complex layers of flavor—these are more on the light and refreshing side. It’s also worth noting that the bottles might not fit in smaller cocktail glasses, which could be a minor inconvenience.
Overall, we think this set is a good buy for anyone looking to enjoy a variety of easy-to-make drinks without a lot of hassle.
Craftmix Cocktail Mixers
Craftmix Cocktail Mixers are a great choice for anyone looking to enjoy low-sugar and customizable drinks with ease.
Pros
- Easy to use, just mix and enjoy
- Made with real fruit, enhancing flavor
- Perfect for cocktails and mocktails
Cons
- Some may find the Stevia taste strong
- Requires additional ingredients (liquor and sparkling water)
- Limited to specific flavors
The Craftmix Variety Pack is incredibly convenient. Each packet is pre-measured, so there’s no need to fuss over proportions. We loved the fact that it included four delicious flavors: Blood Orange Mai Tai, Mango Margarita, Passionfruit Paloma, and Strawberry Mule. They add a nice twist to any party or casual get-together.
We found these mixers versatile. You can use them for both cocktails and mocktails, making them ideal for different crowds. The fact that they’re low in sugar and calories is a huge plus, especially for health-conscious individuals. Just mix with liquor and sparkling water, and you’re all set.
Some users might be sensitive to the Stevia used as a sweetener. This is something to keep in mind if you have a distaste for its flavor. Despite this, we think these mixers make it easy to enjoy a great-tasting drink anywhere, anytime.
Monin HomeCrafted Cocktail Mixers
These mixers offer a quick and easy way to make premium cocktails at home.
Pros
- High-quality natural flavors
- Easy to use with clear instructions
- Versatile for different drinks
Cons
- Some find it too sweet
- Higher price point
- Occasional shipping issues
We tried out Monin’s HomeCrafted Cocktail Mixers and found them to be a great addition to our home bar. The convenience of having a ready-to-use mix with natural flavors is fantastic. We love the variety pack, which includes the Mai Tai, Margarita, and Dragon Fruit Cosmo flavors.
Mixing cocktails was a breeze with these mixers. Each bottle includes easy-to-follow instructions that even beginners can handle. The flavors are well-balanced and deliver a refreshing taste, especially the Dragon Fruit Cosmo with its exotic twist.
Although they are a bit pricier than other options, the quality justifies the cost. Just keep in mind that some might find the sweetness a bit overpowering. Our only minor gripe was that one bottle arrived broken, but overall, we were pleased with the taste and convenience of these mixers.
Proof Syrup Traditional Old Fashioned Cocktail Mixer
If you’re seeking an easy way to make a great Old Fashioned at home, this Proof Syrup is a strong contender.
Pros
- Nutty-sweet flavor from roasted Georgia pecans
- Handcrafted with all-natural ingredients
- Long shelf life of 2 years
Cons
- A bit pricey compared to other brands
- Requires refrigeration after opening
- Rare flavors may take getting used to
We’ve just tried the Proof Syrup Traditional Old Fashioned Cocktail Mixer, and it’s really something special. The pecan flavor offers a unique twist that pairs well with whiskey and rum.
This syrup simplifies cocktail making, freeing us from the hassle of peeling, muddling, and mixing. Just add your favorite aged spirit and you’re all set. The quality of ingredients can be tasted in every sip and makes for a consistently delicious cocktail.
Even though it’s a bit more expensive, the flavor and simplicity it offers are worth it. It’s a must-have for any cocktail lover wanting to elevate their home bar experience.
Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix
If you’re aiming for the perfect Old Fashioned at home, Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix is a must-have.
Pros
- Smooth, layered taste
- Award finalist
- Easy to use
Cons
- May be too sweet for some
- Needs to be used within 3-4 months of opening
- Slightly expensive
Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix is fantastic for making a delicious Old Fashioned cocktail. The handcrafted recipe, featuring organic cherries and fresh orange peel, provides a rich, smooth flavor. I’ve found this mix to be incredibly simple to use—just add ice, your favorite whiskey, and the mix, and you’re ready to enjoy.
What sets this mix apart is its recognition as a Good Foods Award Finalist. The blend of cinnamon, clove, cardamom, and bitter herbs creates a well-rounded taste that truly elevates your drink.
That said, a few things should be noted. The mix can be on the sweeter side, and some might not enjoy that. You’ll want to finish the bottle within a few months of opening, which could be tricky unless you entertain often. Also, it’s a bit pricier compared to other mixes.
Jordan’s Skinny Peach Bellini Mix
If you’re searching for a low-calorie, sugar-free mixer that doesn’t sacrifice taste, Jordan’s Skinny Peach Bellini Mix is worth a try.
Pros
- Zero sugar and carbs
- Pleasant peach flavor
- Simple to mix and serve
Cons
- May be too sweet for some
- Not always available at a low price
- Artificial taste noted by some users
Jordan’s Skinny Peach Bellini Mix provides a flavorful option for those looking to cut back on sugar and calories. We found it easy to use—just a splash in your preferred spirit and you’re good to go. The peach flavor is enjoyable and adds a nice touch to any cocktail.
On the flip side, the sweetness can be a bit overpowering, particularly for those who prefer less sugary drinks. Some users mentioned that the taste feels somewhat artificial, which might be a dealbreaker if you value natural flavors. Also, the price can vary, which might make it less of a bargain.
Despite these drawbacks, we believe this mixer performs well for those following certain dietary preferences. It’s keto-friendly, gluten-free, and non-GMO, catering to a variety of lifestyle needs.
Consider trying Jordan’s Skinny Peach Bellini Mix if you’re aiming for a healthier choice without compromising on the fun and flavor of your favorite drinks.
Highball & Chaser Cocktail Shaker Set
This cocktail shaker set is perfect for anyone wanting to make professional-quality drinks at home.
Pros
- Sleek matte black finish
- Durable construction
- Includes a variety of tools
Cons
- Hand wash only
- Potential for discoloration
- Some parts may show wear over time
The Highball & Chaser Cocktail Shaker Set is an excellent addition to our home bar. The sleek, matte black finish makes it look as good as it performs. Our drinks never tasted better or looked cooler.
We also appreciate the durability of this set. All the tools feel sturdy and well-made. The muddler, shaker, and strainers are built to last and the black bamboo stand keeps everything organized and stylish.
A potential downside is that the set requires hand washing to maintain its finish. Some customers noticed minor discoloration after a few uses. Despite that, it’s a top pick for anyone getting serious about mixology at home.
Thoughtfully Cocktail Mixers
A great gift for anyone who loves trying different cocktail flavors at home.
Pros
- Fun and diverse flavors
- Pre-measured for convenience
- Perfect gift-ready packaging
Cons
- Small portion sizes
- Some flavors are quite sweet
- No alcohol included
These Thoughtfully Cocktail Mixers bring a unique twist to our home bar. Each mixer is inspired by a different global destination, offering a fun way to explore new tastes. For someone who loves mixing drinks, these make the process quick and easy with pre-measured bottles.
We enjoyed trying flavors like Appletini, Peach Bellini, and Mojito. They were vibrant and fun, though on the sweet side. Most of the mixers pair well with rum, which was nice, but it might not be everyone’s preference.
As a gift, this set is spot-on. It comes ready to wrap and looks as good as the pictures. The only downside we noticed was that the portions are quite small. Still, it’s a delightful set for any cocktail enthusiast.
KITESSENSU Cocktail Shaker Set
This cocktail shaker set is a fantastic addition to any home bar, offering quality and convenience for both beginners and seasoned mixologists.
Pros
- Durable stainless steel construction
- Beginner-friendly and leak-proof
- Stylish packaging, perfect for gifting
Cons
- Occasionally tricky to align the lid
- Jigger may rust after a few uses
- Metal quality could be higher
The KITESSENSU Cocktail Shaker Set is an excellent choice for anyone passionate about making cocktails at home. The sturdy 18/8 stainless steel ensures the shaker remains shiny and new even with frequent use. Plus, it’s safe to throw in the dishwasher, which is a huge time-saver.
One major perk of this set is its user-friendliness. The shaker’s leak-proof design means we can mix drinks confidently without worrying about spills. The included 3-piece design, featuring a built-in strainer, makes it easy to whip up a variety of cocktails. The extra recipe guide is a thoughtful touch for those of us just starting out.
While there are so many great things about this shaker set, aligning the lid can be a bit challenging at times. The jigger included might rust after a couple of uses, which can be annoying. This set could benefit from higher quality metal. Even with these minor issues, the KITESSENSU Shaker Set is still a valuable and stylish tool if we love crafting cocktails at home.
Thoughtfully Skinny Cocktail Mixers
These Thoughtfully Skinny Cocktail Mixers are a fantastic addition to any home bar, offering a variety of flavors and a sugar-free formula.
Pros
- Great variety of flavors
- Easy to mix and match
- Sugar-free and low-calorie
Cons
- Bottles can be hard to open
- Some flavors might be too subtle
- Small bottle size
We recently tried the Thoughtfully Skinny Cocktail Mixers, and we were impressed with the wide range of flavors. From Peach Smash to Blood Orange Margarita, there’s something for everyone. The best part is that these mixers are sugar-free, making them a guilt-free indulgence.
Mixing different flavors together was a lot of fun. We loved experimenting to create unique drink combinations. It’s as simple as combining two bottles and adding your favorite alcohol. Whether you’re a cocktail newbie or a seasoned mixologist, these mixers make it easy to whip up delicious drinks at home.
However, we did find the bottles a bit tricky to open. The seals can be stubborn, which might be frustrating for some. Additionally, though the variety is great, a few of the flavors were rather subtle. The bottle size is also smaller than we expected, which is something to keep in mind if you’re planning to use them for a larger gathering.
All in all, Thoughtfully’s Skinny Cocktail Mixers are worth trying if you enjoy experimenting with flavors and need a convenient, low-calorie option for your cocktails.
Buying Guide
Choosing the right cocktail mixer can make all the difference for our drinks. Let’s look at what to consider when buying mixers.
Ingredients
We should always check the ingredient list. Look for natural ingredients and avoid those with too many artificial additives or preservatives. It’s better for the taste and our health.
Flavor Options
Different mixers offer different flavors. Think about the cocktails we want to make. For instance, tonic water for gin and tonic or grenadine for a tequila sunrise. Having a range of flavors can help us be more creative.
Sweetness Level
Some mixers are very sweet, others less so. It’s important to consider the sweetness level to balance our drinks. A table like this can help:
| Mixer Type | Sweetness Level |
|---|---|
| Simple Syrup | High |
| Tonic Water | Medium |
| Club Soda | Low |
Price
We should keep our budget in mind. While some high-end mixers can be pricey, there are many affordable options that are just as good. Compare prices to get the best value.
Packaging Size
Mixers come in various sizes. If we host big parties, larger bottles might be more economical. For casual home use, smaller bottles could be more practical to avoid waste.
Shelf Life
Check the shelf life of mixers. Some need to be refrigerated once opened, while others have a longer shelf life. This can affect how we store and use them.
Using these points, we can find the best cocktail mixers for our needs and enjoy making delicious drinks!
Frequently Asked Questions
Let’s tackle some common questions about cocktail mixers to help you make better drinks.
What are essential syrups to have for cocktail mixing?
Essential syrups include simple syrup, grenadine, and honey syrup. They’re versatile and used in many recipes. Simple syrup is just sugar and water, while grenadine is sweet and fruity. Honey syrup adds a rich sweetness.
How do cocktail mixers differ from juices?
Cocktail mixers are blends of flavors designed for mixing drinks. They often include spices, herbs, and sugars. Juices are natural liquids from fruits or vegetables, usually with no added ingredients. Mixers provide more complexity in cocktails compared to plain juices.
What is a complete set of tools one needs for cocktail mixing?
A complete set includes a shaker, strainer, jigger, muddler, bar spoon, and a mixing glass. These tools help measure, mix, and pour your cocktails with precision. Having these tools ensures you can make a wide variety of drinks effectively.
Can you recommend some cocktail mixer recipes for beginners?
For beginners, try a margarita or a mojito. A margarita needs simple syrup, lime juice, and triple sec mixed with tequila. A mojito requires simple syrup, lime juice, mint leaves, and rum. Both are easy to make and taste great.
Which brand of cocktail mixers is considered the best in the market?
Some top brands include Fever-Tree, Monin, and Master of Mixes. Fever-Tree is known for its premium quality. Monin offers a wide variety of syrups. Master of Mixes provides convenience with pre-mixed options.
Where can I find quality cocktail mixers in retail stores?
You can find quality cocktail mixers at large grocery stores, specialty liquor stores, and online retailers. Look for sections dedicated to cocktail supplies. Some brands also have their own websites where you can purchase directly.
