Bitters are an essential ingredient in cocktail making. They add depth and complexity to drinks, enhancing flavors with just a few drops. Typically made from a blend of herbs, spices, and roots, bitters can transform ordinary cocktails into sophisticated beverages. From classic Old Fashioned to more modern creations, a well-chosen bitter can make all the difference.
When purchasing bitters for cocktails, selection depends on several factors. The flavor profile you want to achieve is crucial, as bitters come in a variety of types such as aromatic, citrus, and herbal. It’s also important to consider the quality of ingredients and the reputation of the brand. Some brands use high-quality, natural ingredients which can impact the final taste of your drink.
We spent countless hours researching and testing various bitters to find the ones that elevate any cocktail with minimal effort.
Best Bitters for Cocktails
Here is our curated list of the best bitters for cocktails. These selections will elevate your drinks and impress your guests.
Angostura Aromatic Bitters
Ideal for home and professional bartenders, Angostura Aromatic Bitters is a must-have for enhancing cocktails.
Pros
- Rich, unique flavor
- Versatile for many drinks
- High-quality ingredients
Cons
- Label sticks to packaging
- Delivery issues reported
- Supply shortages
We’ve been using Angostura Aromatic Bitters for various cocktails, and it’s clear why it’s a staple for many. The rich and distinctive flavor it adds to drinks like Old Fashioneds is unmatched. These bitters bring a wonderfully complex taste to any beverage.
It pairs well with a wide range of spirits, making it a go-to for mixology at home or at a bar. Its versatility also extends beyond cocktails, as it can enhance the flavor of coffee, desserts, and even some savory dishes.
While the product is excellent, some customers reported delivery issues, and the labels can stick to the packaging. Despite these minor setbacks, the quality and taste of these bitters make them an essential item in any bar setup.
Fee Brothers Orange Bitters
A fantastic addition to any cocktail collection, Fee Brothers Orange Bitters offer a delightful citrus twist to your drinks.
Pros
- Bright, zesty orange flavor
- Enhances a variety of cocktails
- Unique scent and taste profile
Cons
- Some might find it not truly bitter
- Packaging issues reported
- Strong flavor can dominate if overused
We recently tried Fee Brothers Orange Bitters in a few of our favorite cocktails, and it was a refreshing experience. The bright flavor is mainly from West Indies orange peels, making it stand out from other bitters we’ve used.
Adding just a few drops to a gin and tonic or martini can elevate the drink’s complexity. The scent of orange lollipops is inviting, and the taste brings a mix of sweet and bitter orange marmalade.
Despite its vibrant flavor, some may notice it’s less bitter than other brands. Careful with the amount, though—a little goes a long way. We’ve also noticed some packaging issues, so handle with care when ordering.
Kingston Bitters Combo Pack
A versatile combo pack that’s perfect for any home bar and adds a delightful twist to your cocktails.
Pros
- Great for enhancing cocktail flavors
- Convenient combo pack with both aromatic and citrus options
- Reliable packaging to prevent damage
Cons
- Bottles are relatively small
- Slightly on the pricier side
- Limited availability
We’ve been using the Kingston Bitters Combo Pack for our cocktails, and it has been a game-changer. The aromatic bitters bring out deep, rich flavors, while the orange bitters add a refreshing citrus twist. This combo pack covers all bases when it comes to flavor enhancement.
The packaging is very reliable, so we don’t worry about the bottles breaking during shipping. This is crucial as these bitters are a staple in our home bar. The convenience of having both types of bitters in one set can’t be overstated.
A minor drawback is the size of the bottles. They are small, so if you use bitters frequently, restocking might be necessary sooner than anticipated. Additionally, the combo pack might be a bit pricey for some buyers. Despite these small downsides, the quality and flavor profile of Kingston Bitters make them a worthwhile addition to any bar.
Bitters “Triple Play” Variety 3-Pack
If you’re looking to elevate your cocktail game, this trio of bitters is a great choice.
Pros
- High-quality flavoring
- Great for a variety of cocktails
- Convenient 3-pack
Cons
- Price can be higher than individual bottles
- Bottles are on the smaller side
- Some flavors might be unique
The Bitters “Triple Play” Variety 3-Pack includes Angostura, Regans, and Peychauds. These are must-haves for any serious cocktail enthusiast. Angostura is a classic that brings depth to any drink, while Regans adds a zesty note with its orange and spice blend. Peychaud’s is essential for those Sazeracs and classic New Orleans cocktails.
Having used this trio, we found that it’s versatile and easy to work with. Angostura’s distinct flavor works perfectly in a Manhattan or Old Fashioned, while Regans adds an exciting twist with its citrusy notes. Peychaud’s bitters bring a touch of history and richness to our drinks, especially in a Whiskey Sour or a Sazerac.
On the downside, the smaller bottle size means you might run out sooner if you’re an avid mixer. The price might seem high, but it’s worth it for the quality and variety. If you’re ready to take your home bar to the next level, this variety pack is a solid investment.
Woodford Reserve Bourbon Bitters Bundle
These bitters are a fantastic addition to any cocktail enthusiast’s collection due to their premium quality and unique flavors.
Pros
- Unique, barrel-aged flavor
- Versatile with different cocktails
- High-quality taste
Cons
- Slightly expensive
- Not widely available
- Specific to dark liquors
We found the Woodford Reserve Bourbon Bitters Bundle to be a notch above the rest. Barrel-aged in genuine bourbon barrels, they bring a robust and distinctive flavor to our cocktails. Each type—Aromatic, Spiced Cherry, Orange, and Chocolate—adds a unique twist to our drinks. These bitters work exceptionally well in an Old Fashioned, bringing out the rich, complex notes of the bourbon.
Using these bitters, we noticed how they pull out the essential flavors in every cocktail. They made our Manhattans and other whiskey drinks pop with that extra layer of depth. The quality is evident from the first sip to the last.
On the downside, these bitters come at a higher price point. However, the premium experience they offer justifies the cost. Availability can also be an issue, as they are not always easy to find in local stores. Despite these minor drawbacks, if you’re serious about your cocktails, the Woodford Reserve Bourbon Bitters Bundle is worth the investment.
Fee Brothers Old Fashioned Aromatic Bitters
These bitters are a must-have for enhancing the flavor profile of any cocktail.
Pros
- Adds complexity to drinks
- Easy to dispense
- Crafted from high-quality ingredients
Cons
- Can be somewhat pricey
- Limited availability in some areas
- Flavor might be too strong for some
Fee Brothers Old Fashioned Aromatic Bitters have really made a mark in our cocktail making. The richness they add to an Old Fashioned or Manhattan is unmatched. Every sip feels like a balanced blend of flavors, with a certain depth that makes the drink more enjoyable.
We love the fact that these bitters come with an easy-to-use dasher cap. It’s simple to control how much goes into each drink, ensuring consistency every time. The hand-wrapped paper packaging also adds a touch of elegance to our bar setup.
The only downside is that Fee Brothers Bitters can be a bit more expensive compared to other brands. Also, they are not always easy to find in local stores. Despite these minor issues, their quality and flavor profile make them worth every penny.
Fee Brothers Cocktail Bitters
This set makes it easy to elevate any cocktail with a variety of robust and unique flavors.
Pros
- Variety of flavors to experiment with
- High-quality, USA-made product
- Perfect gift for cocktail enthusiasts
Cons
- Bottles are small, only 4 fl oz each
- Bitters can’t be returned if damaged
- Higher price point for a sampler set
Fee Brothers offers a fantastic sampler set for anyone looking to enhance their cocktail game. Each bottle offers a unique flavor, from West Indies Orange to Mint Bitters, allowing for endless creativity behind the bar. This variety makes it easy to tailor your drinks to any preference, adding a personal touch to classic cocktails.
One of the best features of this set is the quality and craftsmanship. Made in the USA, Fee Brothers has been a trusted name in bitters since 1863. It’s clear that they know their craft, and it shows in the taste and complexity of each bottle.
Despite the slightly higher price point and the small bottle size, we believe the benefits outweigh these downsides. Whether for personal use or as a gift, this set is perfect for anyone looking to transform their home bar into a mixologist’s dream.
Fee Brothers Cocktail Bitters Set
A superb choice for mixologists looking to expand their cocktail game with diverse and unique flavors.
Pros
- Wide range of flavors
- High-quality ingredients
- Easy to use
Cons
- Some flavors may be too sweet
- Larger upfront cost
- Mint bitters taste like peppermint
Fee Brothers Cocktail Bitters Set provides an excellent palette of flavors that can transform any cocktail. Each bottle brings something unique, from the zesty West Indies Orange to the deep, rich Aztec Chocolate. We found the variety impressive and perfect for both classic and creative cocktails.
The bitters are crafted with care, reflecting the expertise Fee Brothers has developed over generations. This set feels like a spice rack for your bar, elevating both common and rare drinks alike. It’s a joy to explore different combinations and discover your new favorite mix.
While most of the bitters are versatile, we did notice that some flavors are on the sweeter side. This might not appeal to those who prefer stronger, more bitter profiles. Additionally, the peppermint taste of the Mint bitters was unexpected and may not suit everyone’s taste.
In conclusion, this set is a valuable addition for any serious home bartender, offering a great blend of tradition and innovation.
Peychaud’s Aromatic Cocktail Bitters
Great choice for classic cocktail lovers, adding depth and refinement to every drink.
Pros
- Traditional, woodsy flavor
- Essential for classic cocktails
- Consistent, high-quality formula
Cons
- Pricier compared to others
- Limited availability in some areas
- Subtle flavor might not suit every taste
We’ve been using Peychaud’s Aromatic Cocktail Bitters for a while now, and they truly elevate our drinks. The blend of woodsy notes with hints of licorice and caramel adds complexity to every sip. If you enjoy classic cocktails like Manhattans or Old Fashioneds, Peychaud’s is a must-have.
This bitters is particularly great because it doesn’t overpower the drink. Instead, it complements the flavors, creating a balanced and enjoyable cocktail. It’s also fantastic to know it’s made in New Orleans and has been around since the 1800s, which speaks to its quality and enduring popularity.
Despite the slightly higher price and occasional difficulty finding it, we think it’s worth it. The quality and flavor it brings are unmatched, making our cocktail experience richer and more enjoyable. Whether you’re a seasoned mixologist or just love a good drink, we recommend giving it a try.
Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix
This mix offers a quick and enjoyable way to craft a delicious Old Fashioned at home.
Pros
- Handcrafted with high-quality ingredients
- Good Foods Award finalist
- Easy to use, just pour and stir
Cons
- Limited shelf life after opening
- Some find it too sweet
- Higher price point
We love this mix for its artisanal touch and the balance it brings to an Old Fashioned. The blend of tart cherries and fresh orange zest, combined with spices like cinnamon and clove, creates a rich, complex flavor. The fact that it was a Good Foods Award finalist adds to its credibility.
Using it is straightforward: just fill your glass with ice, add the syrup, then your choice of whiskey, bourbon, or rye, and stir it up. Whether you’re a newbie or an experienced home mixologist, this mix makes it easy to whip up a great drink in no time.
One point to keep in mind is the shelf life; it’s best used within 3-4 months after opening. Also, while some might find the sweetness levels just right, others might need to tweak their recipe. Given the quality, the slightly higher price is understandable, but it’s something to consider.
Buying Guide
When buying bitters for cocktails, we should consider a few key points to ensure we get the best product for our needs.
Flavor Varieties
Common Flavors:
- Orange
- Aromatic
- Lemon
Unique Flavors:
- Chocolate
- Coffee
- Grapefruit
Different bitters add different flavors to cocktails. We should pick a few varieties to match our favorite drinks.
Alcohol Content
Bitters usually contain alcohol. We need to check the alcohol content, usually listed as ABV (alcohol by volume). This can range between 35% to 45%. Higher alcohol content might mean a stronger flavor.
Ingredients
It is important to read ingredient lists. Let’s look for natural ingredients like herbs, spices, and fruit extracts. Avoid artificial flavors and colors.
Bottle Size
Bitters come in different bottle sizes. Common sizes are:
- 2 oz (60 ml)
- 4 oz (120 ml)
Smaller bottles are ideal for occasional use, while larger bottles are better for frequent bartenders.
Price Point
We should compare prices to find a product that fits our budget. More expensive bitters might offer more complex flavors, but there are affordable options with great taste as well.
Packaging
Look at the packaging for ease of use. We want a bottle with a dropper or dasher top for precise pouring. Some bottles come with decorative designs, which can be a nice touch.
By considering these features, we can choose the best bitters for our cocktails, enhancing the flavors and overall experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
Bitters are a key ingredient in many cocktails, enhancing flavor and complexity. Here, we explore essential bitters, how they work, popular uses, and more.
What are the essential bitters for a well-stocked home bar?
Angostura bitters, orange bitters, and Peychaud’s bitters are staples. These cover a variety of flavors and uses in classic and modern cocktails.
How do bitters enhance the flavor of a cocktail?
Bitters add depth, balance, and complexity. They bring together ingredients and can emphasize certain flavors, making the drink more enjoyable.
What are some popular cocktails that use Angostura bitters?
Angostura bitters are essential in classics like the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, and Whiskey Sour. They bring a rich, aromatic quality to these drinks.
Can homemade bitters be used in classic cocktails, and if so, how?
Homemade bitters can be great in classic cocktails. They allow for customization of flavors. Start by using them in place of commercial bitters in recipes to see how they change the drink.
Are there any notable differences between aromatic and orange bitters in mixology?
Aromatic bitters like Angostura have a spicy, herbal profile. Orange bitters, on the other hand, offer a citrusy, zesty note. Use them to match the flavor profile of your cocktail.
What are some lesser-known bitters that can be used in innovative cocktail recipes?
Look for chocolate bitters, celery bitters, and lavender bitters. These can add unique twists and unexpected notes to your drinks, making them stand out.
